Who Was Tammy Zywicki?

Tammy Zywicki was a bright, ambitious, and well-loved college student from Evanston, Illinois. At just 21 years old, she had already shown exceptional promise. She was academically gifted, compassionate, and deeply committed to social justice. Friends described her as kind, thoughtful, and driven and someone who genuinely cared about people.

True Crime Weekly is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Tammy was a student at Grinnell College in Iowa, where she was preparing for a future that many believed would include law school or public service. 

She had worked as a camp counselor, volunteered frequently, and had a strong sense of independence.

That independence would ultimately place her in a vulnerable situation.

The Trip That Changed Everything

On August 23, 1992, Tammy set out alone from Evanston to Grinnell about a 6-hour drive to return to college for the fall semester. 

Before leaving, her car experienced mechanical trouble. Despite concerns, she chose to make the drive anyway, planning to stop if needed.

At around 11:45 a.m., Tammy was seen at a rest stop near LaSalle, Illinois, along Interstate 80. Her car had broken down completely. Witnesses reported that she appeared calm and was using the payphone.

Here’s where the case takes the turn.

Subscribe now

Last Known Sightings

Multiple witnesses later told police they saw Tammy speaking with a man described as:

• White
• Late 20s to early 30s
• Stocky build
• Possibly driving a blue or green semi-truck

The man appeared to be offering help.

Tammy accepted assistance.

She was never seen alive again.

When She Didn’t Arrive

Tammy was expected to arrive at Grinnell College that evening. When she didn’t show and didn’t call her family immediately grew concerned. This was unlike her. Tammy was reliable and communicative.

Police were notified quickly, and within days, her disappearance became a major investigation spanning multiple states.

The Grim Discovery

On August 27, 1992, four days after she vanished, Tammy’s body was found in a cornfield near Monroe, Wisconsin, approximately 300 miles from where she was last seen.

She had been:

• Sexually assaulted
• Strangled
• Left partially concealed in the field

The condition of her body suggested she had been held for some time before being killed.

Subscribe now

The Investigation: A Truck Stop Killer?

Early on, investigators believed Tammy had been abducted by a long-haul truck driver. This theory was based on:

• The rest stop location
• Witness descriptions
• The distance her body was transported
• The isolation of trucking routes

Police interviewed thousands of truck drivers, checked logbooks, and followed tips from across the country. More than 1,000 leads poured in.

But none stuck.

A Pattern

Tammy’s case is often discussed alongside other unsolved rest-stop abductions from the late 1980s and early 1990s. Investigators believe her killer:

• Was comfortable traveling long distances
• Knew how to avoid detection
• Likely had prior violent offenses
• Possibly committed other murders

Yet no confirmed connection has ever been made.

Missed Opportunities & Frustrations

Key challenges in the case:

• No DNA match (DNA technology was limited in 1992)
• No confirmed vehicle identification
• Witness memories varied
• The transient nature of trucking made tracking suspects difficult

Tammy’s car was later found abandoned but it offered little forensic value.

True Crime Weekly is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

A Family That Never Gave Up

Tammy’s family spent decades advocating for justice. They pushed for improved safety at rest stops and awareness about accepting help from strangers. 

Her case helped inspire reforms in roadside assistance awareness for women traveling alone.

Despite years passing, her loved ones still believe the right tip could solve the case.

Tammy Zywicki did everything right she was careful, intelligent, and prepared. Yet she encountered the wrong person at the wrong moment.

Someone knows who killed her.