A Town That Changed Forever

Bardstown, Kentucky is known for bourbon, history, and small-town charm.

But between 2013 and 2016, the town experienced a string of deaths so disturbing and so interconnected that it became known nationwide as one of America’s most unsettling modern murder clusters.

Five people died.
Some cases remain unsolved.
And many residents believe the full truth has never been told.

True Crime Weekly is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

The Timeline of Death

1. Officer Jason Ellis (2013)

A respected police officer was ambushed and killed while responding to what appeared to be a disabled vehicle. His murder remains unsolved.

2. Kathy & Samantha Netherland (2014)

A mother and daughter were found brutally murdered in their home. The scene suggested rage and personal motive.

3. Crystal Rogers (2015)

A young mother disappeared after a night out. Her car was found abandoned with her belongings inside. She has never been found.

4. Tommy Ballard (2016)

Crystal Rogers’ father was shot and killed while hunting on family property.

Five deaths.
One town.
No full resolution.

True Crime Weekly is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

The Case That Changed Everything: Crystal Rogers

Crystal’s disappearance ignited national attention. She was last seen with her boyfriend. Her car was found with:

• Keys inside
• Purse inside
• Phone missing

Despite suspects being named publicly, no charges were ever filed.

Her family never stopped pushing for answers.

A Father Silenced

In 2016, Tommy Ballard, Crystal’s father, was shot and killed while hunting. His death was ruled a homicide.

To many, it felt like:

• A warning
• A silencing
• An escalation

His murder deepened fears that someone was actively protecting secrets.

A Police Officer’s Unanswered Murder

Officer Jason Ellis’ killing remains one of the most troubling aspects of the Bardstown saga. He was ambushed with a shotgun in what appeared to be a planned execution.

The possibility that he was targeted because of something he knew has never been ruled out.

Are the Cases Connected?

Authorities insist not all cases are officially linked.

The public and many investigators disagree.

Shared elements include:

• Extreme violence
• Personal targeting
• Limited cooperation
• Delayed justice
• Witness fear

Whether one killer or multiple actors were involved remains unknown.

The Investigation’s Failures

Criticism has focused on:

• Mishandled evidence
• Conflicts of interest
• Lack of transparency
• Witness intimidation fears

Multiple agencies have stepped in over the years, yet major breakthroughs remain elusive.