A Child Taken on Her Walk to School

True Crime Weekly is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

A Normal Morning That Ended in Horror

January 22, 2017, began like any other school day for Alianna DeFreeze, a bright, artistic 13-year-old from Toledo, Ohio. It was still dark when she left her home that morning, bundled against the cold, walking a familiar route toward her bus stop.

She never made it.

By the time the sun rose, Alianna had vanished and within hours, her disappearance would trigger one of the most intense manhunts Toledo had ever seen.

Subscribe now

Who Alianna Was

Alianna was described by family and friends as creative, loving, and deeply expressive. She loved drawing, fashion, and music. Teachers remembered her as quiet but kind, with a gentle presence and a strong sense of individuality.

She was a normal teenager with normal dreams and that’s what makes her story so devastating.

She wasn’t in trouble.
She wasn’t sneaking out.
She wasn’t meeting anyone.

She was walking to school.

The Disappearance

Alianna left her home around 6:30 a.m. to walk to her bus stop, a route she had taken countless times before. When she didn’t arrive at school, concern quickly turned into panic.

Family members reported her missing, and Toledo police launched an immediate search. Within hours:

• Helicopters were deployed
• K-9 units canvassed neighborhoods
• Hundreds of volunteers joined the search
• The FBI became involved

Time mattered and everyone knew it.

The Discovery 

Later that afternoon, searchers made a horrific discovery in an abandoned house just blocks from Alianna’s home.

Alianna’s body was found inside.

The crime scene was brutal.

She had been abducted, sexually assaulted, and murdered. Evidence indicated a violent struggle, and investigators quickly determined that this was a targeted, opportunistic attack the kind that happens in moments, not months.

The person responsible was nearby.

The Suspect

Police attention quickly focused on James Worley, a 57-year-old man who lived close to Alianna’s walking route. Worley had a disturbing criminal history, including:

• Prior convictions for kidnapping
• Violent sexual assault
• Weapons violations

Despite this history, he was living freely in the neighborhood.

Search warrants executed at Worley’s home revealed overwhelming evidence:

• Alianna’s DNA
• A basement containing restraints
• Tools consistent with the crime
• Items suggesting prior violent fantasies

The case against him was swift and airtight.

A Predator Hiding 

Investigators later revealed that Worley had been watching the area. He knew children walked alone in the early morning hours. He knew which houses were vacant. He knew how quickly he could act without being seen.

This wasn’t random chaos.

It was predatory calculation.

Alianna crossed paths with the worst possible person at the worst possible moment.

The Trial

Worley was charged with aggravated murder, kidnapping, rape, and burglary. Prosecutors sought the death penalty, citing:

• His prior violent history
• The cruelty of the crime
• The vulnerability of the victim

During trial, graphic evidence and testimony painted a disturbing picture of Worley’s mindset and actions. The jury found him guilty on all counts.

In 2018, James Worley was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, avoiding the death penalty only due to jury deadlock during sentencing.

Community Outrage and Lasting Questions

Alianna’s murder sent shockwaves through Toledo and beyond. Parents demanded answers:

• Why was a known violent offender living near children?
• Why weren’t stricter monitoring measures in place?
• Could this have been prevented?

Her case reignited national conversations about:

• Sex offender supervision
• Early-morning school safety
• The vulnerability of children walking alone
• Community awareness versus systemic protection

Alianna’s Legacy

In the aftermath of her death, Alianna’s family worked to honor her memory and advocate for child safety. Vigils, murals, and memorials appeared across Toledo reminders of a life stolen far too soon.

Her name became a rallying cry:
Protect our children. Watch our neighborhoods. Do better.